by Serguey Shinder
I made an error that cost real money. Not a fortune, but enough that it would appear in a report somebody read, and it was unambiguously mine, the result of a decision I had made quickly and without checking something I should have checked. I discovered it myself, before anyone else did, on a quiet afternoon with nobody watching, and I spent the next hour doing arithmetic of a very particular kind, which was working out whether anyone would ever find out.
The honest answer was that they probably would not. The mistake was already in the past, the damage had already happened, and the trail led back to me only if somebody went looking with a reason to look. I could have fixed the underlying cause quietly, said nothing, and carried on. I want to be clear that I seriously considered it, because I think the version of this story where the narrator never wavers is a lie people tell to make themselves comfortable.
What made me speak up was not virtue. It was something colder. I realised that if I said nothing, I would spend the following months maintaining the silence, and every conversation about that system would be a conversation I was quietly managing. The cost of hiding a mistake is not paid once at the moment of hiding. It is paid continuously, in vigilance, forever, and I did not want to carry that around.
So I told my manager, badly, in a rush, with more apology than the situation warranted. And the thing I remember most clearly is how little happened. He asked what had caused it, we talked about the check that had been missing, we agreed on the change that would stop it recurring, and that was essentially the end of it. The disaster I had spent an hour rehearsing did not arrive. What arrived was a slightly awkward conversation and a better process.
I have thought a lot since about the gap between those two things, the catastrophe I imagined and the meeting I got. Most of the fear was not about consequences. It was about being seen as someone who makes mistakes, which is a fear that assumes everyone else has been operating without any, and that assumption does not survive five minutes of honest conversation with anyone experienced.
What I actually gained was strange and slow. People started bringing me their own errors, early, before they had grown. Not because I had done anything impressive, but because I had demonstrated that admitting one here did not end badly, and that demonstration turned out to be worth far more than the mistake had cost. The reputation I was protecting by considering silence was smaller and more brittle than the one I got by giving it up.
– Serguey Asael Shinder
Leave a Reply