by Serguey Shinder
When I started making music seriously, I could not tolerate a gap. Every empty space in a piece felt like a failure, a hole I was obligated to fill, evidence that I had run out of ideas. So I filled everything. Every bar had something in it, every moment had a part playing, every silence got hurriedly patched over with a fill or a harmony or a texture, and the results were dense and busy and, I eventually admitted, exhausting to listen to.
The fear underneath this was simple, though it took me a long time to name it. I was afraid that silence would read as absence, that a listener hearing a gap would think I had nothing to put there. So I proved my presence constantly, filling every space to demonstrate that I was working, that there was always something happening, that I had not run out. The music was less an expression than a nervous insistence that I had things to say.
What I did not understand is that silence is not absence. It is part of the music, maybe the most powerful part, because it is the thing that gives everything else its shape. A note only lands because of the quiet around it. A phrase only breathes because there is space for it to breathe into. By filling every gap, I had not added value. I had removed contrast, and contrast was the thing that made any of it mean anything.
The first time I deliberately left a real silence in a piece, a genuine pause where the instinct screamed to put something, I felt exposed, like I had left a sentence unfinished in public. But when I listened back, the silence was not empty at all. It was full of the note that had just ended and the note that was about to begin, charged with both, and it did more for the piece than anything I could have crammed into it.
I came to understand that the courage to leave a space is a kind of confidence. Filling everything is what you do when you are afraid the music cannot stand on its own, when you do not trust the parts you have to carry the weight without constant reinforcement. Trusting a silence means trusting that what surrounds it is strong enough to make the emptiness speak, and that trust only comes when you stop being afraid of looking like you have nothing to say.
Now I treat silence as a thing I place rather than a thing I avoid. The hardest skill I have found in music is not knowing what to play. It is knowing what to leave out, and having the nerve to leave it, and understanding that the space I was so afraid of was never emptiness. It was the room the music needed to be heard.
– Serguey Asael Shinder
Leave a Reply